Logo

American Heart Association

  2
  0


Final ID: Su3087

Sex Disparities in Enrollment of Cardiovascular Trials: A Meta-Analysis of ClinicalTrials.gov Listings

Abstract Body (Do not enter title and authors here):
Background: Despite increasing recognition of sex differences in the burden of cardiovascular (CV) diseases, women have historically been underrepresented in clinical trials.

Aims: The study aimed to systematically quantify the extent of sex disparity in the enrollment of CV trials and explore the annual enrollment trends of women in CV trials.

Methods: The analysis included studies that: (1) were registered in ClinicalTrials.gov up to February 2024; (2) were randomized trials involving ≥1 intervention; (3) investigated ≥1 CV condition, as determined by Medical Subject Heading descriptors. The exclusion criteria were: (1) studies without available enrollment information; (2) studies exclusively enrolling men or women; and (3) studies with ≤100 participants. We computed enrollment disparity difference (EDD), defined as the difference between the proportion of women in trial participants and the proportion of women with CV diseases in the general population, based on the Global Burden of Disease estimates matched by country/geographic region and enrollment period. Random-effects meta-analysis was performed to summarize the overall enrollment disparity. Subgroup analysis by trial characteristics was conducted. Meta-regression was used to assess the association of enrollment disparity with the start year of the trials.

Results: A total of 1,687 CV trials were identified from 484,781 studies. Among 2,198,317 trial participants for whom sex was reported, 819,570 (37.3%) were women. EDD in CV trials was -0.105 (95% CI, -0.113 to -0.097), indicating that women were under-enrolled by 10.5% (Figure 1). Except for valvular heart disease trials, disparities were evident across other CV disease trials, with the most remarkable under-enrollment of women in peripheral artery disease trials (-0.302 [95% CI, -0.324 to -0.279]). Disparities were more prominent in trials with larger sample sizes, longer study durations, device or procedural interventions, and data monitoring committee oversight (p<0.001 for subgroup differences; Figure 2). There was a significant yet modest improvement in the representation of women over time (increase of 0.0028 [95% CI, 0.0011 to 0.0045] in EDD per start year of trials; p=0.001; Figure 3).

Conclusion: Women remain substantially underrepresented in CV trials, particularly in peripheral artery disease trials. The findings underscore the imperative for interventions to mitigate sex inequity in the enrollment of CV trials.
  • Chi, Gerald  ( Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center , Boston , Massachusetts , United States )
  • Lee, Jane  ( Baim Institute for Clinical Research , Boston , Massachusetts , United States )
  • Gibson, Charles  ( Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center , Boston , Massachusetts , United States )
  • Author Disclosures:
    Gerald Chi: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Researcher:CSL Behring:Active (exists now) ; Researcher:Bayer Pharmaceuticals:Active (exists now) ; Researcher:Janssen Scientific Affairs:Active (exists now) | Jane Lee: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Charles Gibson: No Answer
Meeting Info:

Scientific Sessions 2024

2024

Chicago, Illinois

Session Info:

Sex Differences in CVD 2

Sunday, 11/17/2024 , 03:15PM - 04:15PM

Abstract Poster Session

More abstracts on this topic:
Association of Sociodemographic Characteristics on Costs of Care in Patients with Obstructive Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy

Reza Nosheen, Butzner Michael, Batra Kirti, Amos Qiana, Buikema Ami, Anderson Amy, Shreay Sanatan, Owens Anjali

A Multicentre Study for Hands Only CPR (HOCPR) training assessment towards building a ‘Nation of Life Savers” in India

Ravikumar Thanjavur, Sarma Kvs, Ravikumar Thanjavur, Sarkar Manuj, Debnath Dhrubajyoti, Behera Priyamadhaba, Ghate Jayshri, Trikha Divay, Samantaray A, Madhavi K

More abstracts from these authors:
Shifting trends and study characteristics associated with randomization, blinding, and data monitoring committee oversight of cardiovascular trials: analysis of ClinicalTrials.gov listings from 2000 to 2023

Chi Gerald, Bahit Maria, Castro Molina Alberto, Korjian Serge, Vitarello Clara, Nara Paul, Shaunik Alka, Gibson Charles

Evaluating the Clinical Reasoning of GPT-4, Grok, and Gemini in Different Fields of Cardiology

Reyes-rivera Jonathan, Chi Gerald, Angulo Stephanie, Moore Michelle, Lopez-quijano Juan M., Samman Abdallah, Gordillo-moscoso Antonio A., Ali Asif, Castro Molina Alberto, Romero-lorenzo Marco, Ali Sajid, Gibson Charles, Saucedo Jorge, Calandrelli Matias, García Cruz Edgar, Bahit Cecilia

You have to be authorized to contact abstract author. Please, Login
Not Available