Logo

American Heart Association

  1
  0


Final ID: TP5

Observed to Expected Sex and Racial Makeup of Trial Participants in Completed StrokeNet Trials

Abstract Body: Introduction: Successful clinical trials demonstrate that new treatments are safe and efficacious. Adequate representation of underrepresented groups within clinical trials is important to build trust in research institutions and promote fairness in research. We sought to investigate whether participants in recently completed NIH StrokeNet trials were representative by race and sex compared to the expected trial population estimated from a population-based stroke study.

Methods: Since 2014, in collaboration with NIH StrokeNet, we have prepared feasibility analyses for proposed clinical trials. Thus far, 3 trials have been completed: ARCADIA, DEFUSE 3, and MOST. Our analyses used data from the 2010 epoch of the Greater-Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky Stroke Study (GCNKSS). DEFUSE 3 and MOST investigated acute treatments for ischemic stroke while ARCADIA investigated secondary stroke prevention therapies. Each study's inclusion and exclusion criteria were applied to the GCNKSS population and a percentage of eligible patients was generated. Retrospectively, we calculated the proportion of those eligible patients by race and sex and compared that to the observed proportion from each trial using Chi-square test.

Results: In 2010, there were 2265 ischemic strokes, of which 248, 74, and 135 were predicted to be eligible for ARCADIA, DEFUSE 3, and MOST, respectively. The application of the I/E criteria for each trial was limited by data available in GCNKSS, and all proposed exclusions were not able to be accounted for (namely, imaging data for DEFUSE 3 and EKG/TTE findings for ARCADIA). All 3 trials enrolled an expected number of females but DEFUSE 3 enrolled less Black participants than would have been expected (O:E ratio 0.3, p-value <0.01). Full results are available in Table 1 and Figure 1.

Conclusion: We found no statistically significant difference between the proportion of patients predicted to be eligible stratified by race and sex and the actual proportions of those enrolled for ARCADIA and MOST. For DEFUSE 3, the observed enrollment for black participants was lower than expected. All three trials enrolled near or greater than 50% females. Importantly, site selection may impact a trial’s ability to enroll different minority populations and certain clinical trial exclusion criteria may also asymmetrically affect Black patients and women. These findings should reassure that StrokeNet trials enroll a diverse population.
  • Stanton, Robert  ( University of Cincinnati , Cincinnati , Ohio , United States )
  • Barreto, Andrew  ( UNIVERSITY TEXAS HEALTH SCI HOUSTON , Houston , Texas , United States )
  • Grotta, James  ( Memorial Hermann Health System , Houston , Texas , United States )
  • Derdeyn, Colin  ( UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINA , Charlottesville , Virginia , United States )
  • Haverbusch, Mary  ( UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI , Cincinnati , Ohio , United States )
  • Robinson, David  ( University of Cincinnati , Cincinnati , Ohio , United States )
  • Aziz, Yasmin  ( University of Cincinnati , Cincinnati , Ohio , United States )
  • Kleindorfer, Dawn  ( Michigan Medicine , Ann Arbor , Michigan , United States )
  • Kissela, Brett  ( University of Cincinnati , Cincinnati , Ohio , United States )
  • Khatri, Pooja  ( UNIV OF CINCINNATI NEUROLOGY , Cincinnati , Ohio , United States )
  • Broderick, Joseph  ( UC Neuroscience Institute , Cincinnati , Ohio , United States )
  • Skolarus, Lesli  ( Northwestern University , Chicago , Michigan , United States )
  • Boden-albala, Bernadette  ( University of California, Irvine , Irvine , California , United States )
  • Albers, Greg  ( Stanford University Medical Center , Stanford , California , United States )
  • Kamel, Hooman  ( Weill Cornell Medicine , New York , New York , United States )
  • Adeoye, Opeolu  ( Washington University , Saint Louis , Missouri , United States )
  • Author Disclosures:
    Robert Stanton: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Andrew Barreto: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | James Grotta: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Consultant:Frazer Ltd:Active (exists now) ; Advisor:Prolong Pharma:Active (exists now) ; Advisor:Acticor:Active (exists now) ; Advisor:Diamedica:Active (exists now) | Colin Derdeyn: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Consultant:Penumbra:Active (exists now) ; Individual Stocks/Stock Options:Pulse Therapeutics:Active (exists now) ; Consultant:SilkRoad:Past (completed) | Mary Haverbusch: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | David Robinson: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Yasmin Aziz: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Dawn Kleindorfer: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Advisor:Bayer:Past (completed) | Brett Kissela: No Answer | Pooja Khatri: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Cerenovus:Active (exists now) ; Other (please indicate in the box next to the company name):Drug and assays for NIH funded SISTER trial:Active (exists now) ; Royalties/Patent Beneficiary:UpToDate (online publication):Active (exists now) ; Advisor:Basking Biosciences:Active (exists now) ; Advisor:Roche:Active (exists now) ; Advisor:Shionogi:Active (exists now) ; Advisor:Lumosa:Active (exists now) | Joseph Broderick: No Answer | Lesli Skolarus: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Bernadette Boden-Albala: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Greg Albers: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Consultant:Genentech:Past (completed) ; Individual Stocks/Stock Options:iSchemaView:Active (exists now) ; Consultant:iSchemaView:Active (exists now) | Hooman Kamel: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Other (please indicate in the box next to the company name):Financial disclosures for Hooman Kamel: a PI role in the ARCADIA trial, which received in-kind study drug from the BMS-Pfizer Alliance for Eliquis and ancillary study support from Roche Diagnostics; a Deputy Editor role for JAMA Neurology; clinical trial steering/executive committee roles for the STROKE-AF (Medtronic), LIBREXIA-AF (Janssen), and LAAOS-4 (Boston Scientific) trials; consulting or endpoint adjudication committee roles for AbbVie, AstraZeneca, Boehringer Ingelheim, and Novo Nordisk; and household ownership interests in TETMedical, Spectrum Plastics Group, and Ascential Technologies.:Active (exists now) | Opeolu Adeoye: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
Meeting Info:
Session Info:

Acute Treatment: Systemic Thrombolysis and Cerebroprotection Posters II

Thursday, 02/06/2025 , 07:00PM - 07:30PM

Poster Abstract Session

More abstracts on this topic:
A distinct clot transcriptomic signature is associated with atrial fibrillation-derived ischemic stroke in the INSIGHT Registry

Seah Carina, Rivet Dennis, Fraser Justin, Kellner Christopher, Devarajan Alex, Vicari James, Dabney Alan, Baltan Selva, Sohrabji Farida, Pennypacker Keith, Nanda Ashish, Woodward Britton

10-Year Trend Analysis of Medicare Payment in Stroke Inpatient Hospital Admission

Wong Ka-ho, Krothapalli Neeharika, Littig Lauren, Champagne Alison, Majersik Jennifer, Reddy Vivek, De Havenon Adam

More abstracts from these authors:
Predicting Hemorrhagic Transformation After Thrombolytics with Computed Tomography using a 3D Convolutional Neural Network

Stanton Robert, Kleindorfer Dawn, Khatri Pooja, Kissela Brett, Vagal Achala, Williamson Brady, Maloney Thomas, Khandwala Vivek, Behymer Tyler, Robinson David, Aziz Yasmin, Woo Daniel, Broderick Joseph

The Impact of Electronic Consent on Participant Recruitment in an Acute Ischemic Stroke Clinical Trial

Davis Shannon Iris, Barreto Andrew, Broderick Joseph, Grotta James, Derdeyn Colin, Streib Christopher, Staugaitis Abbey, Rines Ian, Roy Akash, Rogers Anthony, Stalin Karen, Bentho Oladi, Khatri Pooja, Adeoye Opeolu

You have to be authorized to contact abstract author. Please, Login
Not Available

Readers' Comments

We encourage you to enter the discussion by posting your comments and questions below.

Presenters will be notified of your post so that they can respond as appropriate.

This discussion platform is provided to foster engagement, and simulate conversation and knowledge sharing.

 

You have to be authorized to post a comment. Please, Login or Signup.


   Rate this abstract  (Maximum characters: 500)