Logo

American Heart Association

  99
  0


Final ID: 064

Fairness Heterogeneity of the PREVENT Equations in US Young Adults

Abstract Body: Background
In 2023, the AHA published Predicting Risk of cardiovascular disease EVENTs (PREVENT), a new set of race-agnostic risk prediction equations that estimate 10-year risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) in US adults ages 30-79 years. Equations include a base model and a model adding social deprivation index (SDI).

Aim
To evaluate fairness of the base and SDI-enhanced PREVENT equations across race/ethnicity and sex groups in US young adults.

Methods
We included adults aged 20-39 years enrolled between 2008-2009 without a history of CVD from Kaiser Permanente Southern California. From the eligible sample of 266,378, we randomly selected 50,000 young adults for computational efficiency. Primary outcome was incident CVD (defined as myocardial infarction, fatal coronary heart disease, fatal and nonfatal stroke, and heart failure) at 10 years. We estimated 10-year CVD risk using the PREVENT base and SDI-enhanced models. To assess race-sex specific model performance, we used Brier score, Harrell’s C, and mean calibration in each group. Overall algorithmic fairness was evaluated by (1) fair calibration, which measures whether agreement between predicted and observed risk is equally accurate across groups using Hosmer-Lemeshow goodness-of-fit and pairwise Wilcoxon signed-rank tests, and (2) concordance imparity, which measures the largest deviation of discriminative abilities across racial and ethnic groups by taking the difference between maximum and minimum Harrell’s C across groups.

Results
We included 50,000 young adults who were mean (SD) age 31.7 (5.4) years, 61.3% female, and 51.1% Hispanic, who had 312 incident CVD events by 10 years. Performance metrics were similar in the base and SDI-enhanced equations. Models were under-calibrated in Black and White females and Asian and Black males, indicating observed risk was higher than predicted risk. Agreement between predicted and observed risk was not equally accurate across racial and ethnic groups in males or females (biased calibrated). Discriminative abilities also varied across groups, with Harrell’s C highest in Black males and lowest in Asian females. Concordance imparity was similar in the base and SDI-enhanced models (0.097 vs. 0.095).

Conclusion
The PREVENT equations may not provide consistent risk predictions for young adults across race/ethnicity and sex groups, which could lead to unequal CVD prevention efforts. Addition of SDI to the PREVENT equations did not provide improvement in fairness.
  • Gauen, Abigail  ( Northwestern University , Chicago , Illinois , United States )
  • Petito, Lucia  ( Northwestern University , Chicago , Illinois , United States )
  • Zhou, Mengnan  ( Kaiser Permanente , Pasadena , California , United States )
  • Zhou, Hui  ( Kaiser Permanente , Pasadena , California , United States )
  • An, Jaejin  ( Kaiser Permanente , Pasadena , California , United States )
  • Zhang, Yiyi  ( Columbia University , New York City , New York , United States )
  • Reynolds, Kristi  ( KAISER PERMANENTE , Pasadena , California , United States )
  • Lloyd-jones, Donald  ( Northwestern University , Chicago , Illinois , United States )
  • Allen, Norrina  ( NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY , Chicago , Illinois , United States )
  • Author Disclosures:
    Abigail Gauen: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Lucia Petito: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Omron Healthcare Co., Ltd.:Active (exists now) ; Consultant:Ciconia Medical, LLC:Past (completed) | Mengnan Zhou: No Answer | Hui Zhou: No Answer | Jaejin An: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Bayer:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):AstraZeneca:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Merck:Past (completed) | Yiyi Zhang: No Answer | Kristi Reynolds: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Donald Lloyd-Jones: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Norrina Allen: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
More abstracts on this topic:
Accuracy Of Stroke Prediction Using The Predicting Risk Of CVD Events Equation Among Diverse Adults Of The Northern Manhattan Study

Mesa Robert, Veledar Emir, Levin Bonnie, Agudelo Christian, Elfassy Tali, Gardener Hannah, Rundek Tatjana, Brown Scott, Yang Eugene, Elkind Mitchell, Gutierrez Jose, Besser Lilah, Gutierrez Carolina

A Nationwide Italian Network for the Clinical and Genetic Diagnosis of Familial Dyslipidemias: The LIPIGEN registry

Casula Manuela, Galimberti Federica, Olmastroni Elena, Arca Marcello, Averna Maurizio, Catapano Alberico

More abstracts from these authors:
Evaluation of 10-Year Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Risk Prediction Performance using the PREVENT versus Pooled Cohort Equations in a US Integrated Healthcare System

Zhou Hui, Safford Monika, An Jaejin, Zhang Yiyi, Zhou Mengnan, Choi Soonie, Reynolds Kristi, Bellows Brandon, Moran Andrew, Colantonio Lisandro, Allen Norrina

Comparison of short- and long-term atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease risk assessment tools in US young adults

Zhang Yiyi, Safford Monika, Colantonio Lisandro, Rana Jamal, Bellows Brandon, Moran Andrew, An Jaejin, Xia Mengying, Reynolds Kristi, Zhou Hui, Zhou Mengnan, Allen Norrina, Gauen Abigail, Petito Lucia, Xanthakis Vanessa

You have to be authorized to contact abstract author. Please, Login
Not Available