Sex-Specific Outcomes of Left Atrial Appendage Occlusion Versus Oral Anticoagulation: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Abstract Body (Do not enter title and authors here): Background Oral anticoagulation (OAC) is the standard for stroke prevention in atrial fibrillation (AF), but high bleeding risk or intolerance limits its use in some patients. Left atrial appendage occlusion (LAAO) has emerged as an alternative, showing similar outcomes to OAC in recent trials for stroke, bleeding, and mortality. However, sex-based differences in outcomes remain underexplored. Women, who face higher AF-related stroke risks, are underrepresented in key LAAO randomized controlled trials (RCTs).
Objective This study evaluates sex-based differences in the effectiveness and safety of LAAO versus OAC in non-valvular AF.
Methods We searched PubMed, Embase, Scopus, and Web of Science through November 2024 for RCTs, secondary analyses, and observational studies comparing LAAO and OAC, including sex-stratified outcomes. Data were pooled using a random-effects model, as risk ratios (RR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI). Review Manager 5.4 was used for statistical analysis.
Results 4 RCTs and 4 observational studies comprising 296,135 males and 289,772 females, were included in the final analysis. Overall, LAAO was associated with a statistically significant reduction in the composite outcome of stroke, embolism, death, and bleeding compared to OAC. In sex-specific subgroup analyses, for the composite outcome, LAAO showed a trend towards a reduction in males, though not statistically significant (RR 0.79[0.59-1.05], P=0.10), while no significant difference was observed in females (RR 0.88[0.70-1.12], P=0.30). LAAO was associated with a statistically significant reduction in bleeding in males (RR 0.61[0.38-0.98], P=0.04), but not females (RR 0.89[0.59-1.36], P=0.60). LAAO also led to a statistically significant reduction in mortality in both males (RR 0.69[0.52-0.92], P=0.01) and females (RR 0.61[0.46-0.81], P=0.0007). No statistically significant difference was found in stroke risk between LAAO and OAC in males (RR 0.80[0.50-1.29], P=0.37) or females (RR 0.82[0.50-1.34], P=0.42).
Conclusion LAAO was associated with significant reductions in stroke, embolism, death, and bleeding compared to OAC. These benefits were consistent across sexes, with no significant differences in treatment effect between males and females. However, further large-scale RCTs are needed to confirm these results. Future studies should prioritize the inclusion of female participants.
Shahabi, Mariam
( Dow University of Health Sciences
, Karachi
, Pakistan
)
Fenrich, Arnold
( Dell Children's Medical Center
, Austin
, Texas
, United States
)
Kalra, Kriti
( Medstar
, Alexandria
, Virginia
, United States
)
Salehi, Negar
( Cleveland Clinic Foundation
, Brecksville
, Ohio
, United States
)
Satish, Priyanka
( Dell Medical School, UT Austin
, Austin
, Texas
, United States
)
Vallabhajosyula, Saraschandra
( Brown Univ Warren Alpert Med School
, Providence
, Rhode Island
, United States
)
Hong, Mauricio
( Dell Medical School, UT Austin
, Austin
, Texas
, United States
)
Hassan, Syed Zawahir
( Dell Medical School, UT Austin
, Austin
, Texas
, United States
)
Ahsan, Muneeba
( Dow University of Health Sciences
, Karachi
, Pakistan
)
Shahzad, Maryam
( Dow University of Health Sciences
, Karachi
, Pakistan
)
Shaikh, Reyan Hussain
( Agakhan Medical College
, Karachi
, Pakistan
)
Waqas, Muhammad
( Jinnah Sindh Medical University
, Karachi
, Pakistan
)
Nazir, Abubakar
( Jewish Hospital-Mercy Health
, Cincinnati
, Ohio
, United States
)
Jamshed, Mian Muinuddin
( Agakhan Medical College
, Karachi
, Pakistan
)
Alvarez, Maximo
( UTRGV School of medicine
, Edinburg
, Texas
, United States
)
Agrawal, Hitesh
( Dell Medical School, UT Austin
, Austin
, Texas
, United States
)
Author Disclosures:
Mariam Shahabi:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Arnold Fenrich:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Kriti Kalra:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Negar Salehi:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Priyanka Satish:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Saraschandra Vallabhajosyula:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Mauricio Hong:No Answer
| Syed Zawahir Hassan:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Muneeba Ahsan:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Maryam Shahzad:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Reyan Hussain Shaikh:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Muhammad Waqas:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Abubakar Nazir:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Mian Muinuddin Jamshed:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Maximo Alvarez:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Hitesh Agrawal:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
Khan Muhammad Aslam, Haider Taimoor, Bhattarai Shraddha, Afzal Hafsa, Khan Bilal, Muhammad Anza, Shafique Nouman, Bhatia Hitesh, Aafreen Asna, Adil Abid Nawaz Khan, Akbar Usman, Khan Alamzaib, Haider Muhammad Adnan
Xu Xiaohong, Preeti Preeti, Yu Ruoying, Shaykhalishahi Hamed, Zhang Cheng, Shen Chuanbin, Li Bei, Tang Naping, Chang Yan, Xiang Qian, Cui Yimin, Lei Xi, Ni Heyu, Zhu Guangheng, Liu Zhenze, Hu Xudong, Slavkovic Sladjana, Neves Miguel, Ma Wenjing, Xie Huifang