Randomized Comparison of Left Atrial Appendage Closure with Oral Anticoagulation after Catheter Ablation for Atrial Fibrillation
Abstract Body (Do not enter title and authors here): Hypothesis and Purpose: Guidelines recommend continuation of anticoagulation following atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation in patients at high risk for stroke. Left atrial appendage closure (LAAC), a mechanical alternative to stroke prevention, has not been studied after AF ablation. Study Design and Methods: OPTION is a multicenter, randomized, FDA pivotal controlled trial (NCT03795298). Population Studied: Patients planned for catheter ablation of AF and elevated CHA2DS2-VASc (male ≥2, female ≥3) were eligible if the ablation occurred 90-180 days prior to or within 10 days of randomization. Intervention: Patients were randomized 1:1 to ablation+LAAC (WATCHMAN FLX) vs ablation+OAC stratified by site and ablation timing (sequential/concomitant to LAAC). Power Calculation: To show noninferiority of LAAC vs OAC for primary efficacy and superiority for primary safety, 1360 patients provides 86% power. Primary End Points: The primary safety endpoint is 36-month (M) non-procedural bleeding based on International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis [ISTH] major bleeding or clinically relevant non-major bleeding definitions. The primary efficacy endpoint is 36M all-cause death, stroke, or systemic embolism. Secondary End Points: The secondary endpoint is 36M ISTH major bleeding. Additional endpoints include primary endpoint components, peridevice leaks and, device-related thrombosis (3M,12 M) and quality of life (12M, 36 M). Outcomes:Between 20May19 and 16Jul21, 1600 patients were randomized to catheter ablation+LAAC (n=803) or ablation+OAC (n=797) at 114 sites. Overall, patients are ~70 years, 34% women, mean CHA2DS2-VASc score is 3.5, and mean HAS-BLED is 1.2. Patients randomized to anticoagulation mostly (95.0%) received a non-warfarin oral anticoagulant. LAAC was performed either concomitant with (40.8%) or sequentially after (59.2%) AF ablation. There were significantly fewer primary safety events with LAAC than anticoagulation (8.5% vs 18.1%; Psuperiority <0.0001). Primary efficacy event rates were comparable between LAAC and anticoagulation (5.3% vs 5.8%; Pnoninferiority <0.0001). Major bleeding rates were comparable between LAAC and anticoagulation (3.9% vs 5.0%; Pnoninferiority <0.0001). Conclusions: Among moderate-high risk patients undergoing AF ablation, LAAC resulted in significantly less non-procedural bleeding than oral anticoagulation, while preserving similarly low rates of stroke, systemic embolism or death.
Wazni, Oussama
(
Cleveland Clinic
, Cleveland , Ohio , United States )
Saliba, Walid
(
Cleveland Clinic
, Cleveland , Ohio , United States )
Nair, Devi
(
St. Bernard's Heart and Vascular Center
, Jonesboro , Arkansas , United States )
Marijon, Eloi
(
European Georges Pompidou Hospital
, Paris , France )
Schmidt, Boris
(
CCB
, Frankfurt , Germany )
Hounshell, Troy
(
Iowa Heart Center
, West Des Moines , Iowa , United States )
Ebelt, Henning
(
Catholic Hospital, Sankt Johann Nepomuk
, Erfurt , Germany )
Skurk, Carsten
(
Deutsches Herzzentrum der Charité (DHZC), Campus Benjamin Franklin
, Berlin , Germany )
Oza, Saumil
(
Ascension St. Vincent’s Medical Center
, Jacksonville , Florida , United States )
Patel, Chinmay
(
UPMC Pinnacle
, Harrisburg , Pennsylvania , United States )
Kanagasundram, Arvindh
(
Vanderbilt University
, Brentwood , Tennessee , United States )
Sadhu, Ashish
(
Phoenix Cardiovascular Research Group
, Phoenix , Arizona , United States )
Sundaram, Sri
(
South Denver Cardiology
, Littleton , Colorado , United States )
Osorio, Jose
(
Grandview Medical Center
, Birmingham , Alabama , United States )
Mark, George
(
The Heart House/Cooper University
, Camden , New Jersey , United States )
Gupta, Madhukar
(
Lindner Center for Research and Education at Christ Hospital
, Cincinnati , Ohio , United States )
Delurgio, David
(
EMORY UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL
, Atlanta , Georgia , United States )
Olson, Jeff
(
St Vincent Heart Center of Indiana
, Carmel , Indiana , United States )
Nielsen-kudsk, Jens Erik
(
Aarhus University Hospital
, Aarhus N , Denmark )
Boersma, Lucas
(
St. Antonius Hospital
, Nieuwegein , Netherlands )
Healey, Jeff
(
McMaster University
, Hamilton , Ontario , Canada )
Phillips, Karen
(
The Brisbane AF Clinic
, Brisbane , Queensland , Australia )
Asch, Federico
(
MedStar Health Research Institute, MEDSTAR WASHINGTON HOSPITAL CENTER
, Washington , District of Columbia , United States )
Roy, Kristine
(
Boston Scientific
, Marlborough , Massachusetts , United States )
Christen, Thomas
(
Boston Scientific
, Marlborough , Massachusetts , United States )
Sutton, Brad
(
Boston Scientific
, Marlborough , Massachusetts , United States )
Stein, Kenneth
(
Boston Scientific Corporation
, Saint Paul , Minnesota , United States )
Reddy, Vivek
(
Mount Sinai Fuster Heart Hospital School of Medicine
, New York City , New York , United States )
Author Disclosures:
Oussama Wazni:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:boston scientific:Active (exists now)
; Speaker:Boston Scientific:Past (completed)
| chinmay patel:No Answer
| Arvindh Kanagasundram:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Speaker:Abbott:Active (exists now)
| Ashish Sadhu:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Advisor:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Speaker:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
| Sri Sundaram:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
| Jose Osorio:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:Biosense Webster:Active (exists now)
| George Mark:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Speaker:Zoll Medical:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Impulse Dynamics:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Abbott:Active (exists now)
| Madhukar Gupta:No Answer
| David Delurgio:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:atricure:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Haemonetics:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:medtronic:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
| Jeff Olson:DO NOT have relevant financial relationships
| Jens Erik Nielsen-Kudsk:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Conformal Medical:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Abbott:Active (exists now)
| Walid Saliba:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Advisor:boston scientific:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:siemens:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:biosense webster:Active (exists now)
| Lucas Boersma:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Medtronic:Active (exists now)
| Jeff Healey:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Research Funding (PI or named investigator):BMS/Pfizer:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Medtronic:Active (exists now)
| Karen Phillips:No Answer
| Federico Asch:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Abbott, Edwards, BSC, Medtronic,Ancora Heart, Neovasc, InnovHeart, Polares Medical:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Ultromics, Us2.ai, Tomtec, GE, egnite:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Corflow, Laminar, Aria CV, COrcym, Tricares, VDyne, Croivalve:Active (exists now)
| Kristine Roy:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Employee:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Individual Stocks/Stock Options:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
| Thomas Christen:No Answer
| Brad Sutton:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Employee:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
| Kenneth Stein:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Executive Role:Boston Scientific :Active (exists now)
| Vivek Reddy:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
| Devi Nair:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:Medtronic :Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Abbott:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Abbott:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Abbott:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Biosense Webster:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Biosense Webster:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Biosense Websterr:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Boston Scientific :Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Medtronic:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Medtronic:Active (exists now)
| Eloi Marijon:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:Zoll:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Abbott:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Medtronic:Active (exists now)
| Boris Schmidt:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:bsci:Active (exists now)
; Speaker:medtronic:Past (completed)
; Consultant:abbott:Active (exists now)
| Troy Hounshell:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Consultant:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Consultant:Medtronic:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Medtronic:Active (exists now)
| Henning Ebelt:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Speaker:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
| Carsten Skurk:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Speaker:Boston Scientific:Past (completed)
; Speaker:Abiomed:Active (exists now)
| Saumil Oza:DO have relevant financial relationships
;
Advisor:Biosense Webster:Active (exists now)
; Speaker:Haemonetics:Active (exists now)
; Ownership Interest:HRCRS:Active (exists now)
; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)
; Individual Stocks/Stock Options:Atricure:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Pacemate:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:GE Electrophysiology :Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Volta Medical:Active (exists now)
; Advisor:Boston Scientific:Active (exists now)