Logo

American Heart Association

  15
  0


Final ID: MDP101

Heterogeneous Treatment Effects of Laryngeal Tube Insertion versus Endotracheal Intubation on Return of Spontaneous Circulation following Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest

Abstract Body: Introduction
Previous work suggested a benefit of laryngeal tube (LT) insertion over endotracheal intubation (ETI) in adults with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA). But, it remains unclear whether the effectiveness of LT insertion differs across patient phenotypes, given the heterogeneous nature of OHCA.

Research Question
Does the benefit of LT insertion vs. ETI for adults with OHCA differ based on patient phenotypes?

Methods
We conducted a retrospective analysis of adults who underwent successful first attempt LT insertion or ETI in the Pragmatic Airway Resuscitation Trial (PART), a clinical trial comparing the effectiveness of LT insertion vs. ETI for adult OHCAs. The outcome was ROSC at ED arrival. We developed a causal forest-based machine learning (ML) model to predict the individualized treatment effects (ITE) of allocation to LT insertion vs. ETI. A quarter of the data were used to construct the tree structure, another quarter of the data was used to make predictions, and the remaining data were used to test the developing model. We estimated the association between the assigned airway and the outcome across the levels of age, sex, witness status, bystander CPR, initial rhythms, ROSC and emesis before airway attempt, and interval from dispatch to airway attempt. Finally, we developed a decision tree model (i.e., policytree) to guide the optimal airway management based on the predicted ITE.

Results
We identified 1,594 patients who underwent first attempt LT insertion or ETI success. 1,010 (63%) were assigned to LT insertion. The ML model revealed that LT insertion was more beneficial in 456 (29%) patients, whereas ETI was more beneficial in 1,138 (71%). The heterogeneous treatment effects (HTE) of LT insertion vs. ETI were derived largely from the time to first airway attempt, and earlier airway attempts favored LT insertion (Fig. 1). The HTE was consistent regardless of patients’ attributes in Fig. 2. The policytree showed LT insertion was preferable to ETI for patients who underwent the initial airway attempt within 18 minutes from dispatch call and did not receive bystander CPR (absolute increase in the probability of ROSC with LT insertion [95%CI], 7.9% [–3.1 to 19.0%], Fig. 3); otherwise, LT insertion’s benefit was limited (–6.7% [–12.1 to –1.3%]).

Conclusion
We identified the HTE of LT insertion vs. ETI on ROSC at ED arrival. Although an external validation is warranted, individualized airway management may optimize prehospital care for OHCA.
  • Osawa, Itsuki  ( Columbia University , New York , New York , United States )
  • Martin-gill, Christian  ( University of Pittsburgh , Pittsburgh , Pennsylvania , United States )
  • Nichol, Graham  ( University of Washington , Seattle , Washington , United States )
  • Shiba, Koichiro  ( Boston University , Boston , Massachusetts , United States )
  • Shimada, Yuichi  ( Columbia University , New York , New York , United States )
  • Stephens, Shannon  ( University of Alabama aBirmingham , Birmingham , Alabama , United States )
  • Wang, Henry  ( The Ohio State University , Columbus , Ohio , United States )
  • Okubo, Masashi  ( University of Pittsburgh , Pittsburgh , Pennsylvania , United States )
  • Callaway, Clifton  ( UNIVERSITY PITTSBURGH , Pittsburgh , Pennsylvania , United States )
  • Aufderheide, Tom  ( Medical College of Wisconsin , Milwaukee , Wisconsin , United States )
  • Carlson, Jestin  ( Saint Vincent Hospital , Erie , Pennsylvania , United States )
  • Daya, Mohamud  ( OHSU , Portland , Oregon , United States )
  • Elmer, Jonathan  ( Univesity of Pittsburgh , Pittsburgh , Pennsylvania , United States )
  • Goto, Tadahiro  ( Yokohama City University , Yokohama , Japan )
  • Guyette, Francis  ( U OF PITTSBURGH , Pittsburgh , Pennsylvania , United States )
  • Idris, Ahamed  ( University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center , Dallas , Texas , United States )
  • Author Disclosures:
    Itsuki Osawa: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Christian Martin-Gill: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Graham Nichol: No Answer | Koichiro Shiba: No Answer | Yuichi Shimada: No Answer | Shannon Stephens: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Consultant:Infrascan:Past (completed) ; Consultant:CelCor Therapeutics:Past (completed) ; Consultant:CSL Behring:Past (completed) ; Consultant:Arsenal Medical:Past (completed) | Henry Wang: No Answer | Masashi Okubo: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Clifton Callaway: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Ownership Interest:IntelliCardio:Expected (by end of conference) | Tom Aufderheide: DO have relevant financial relationships ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):ZOLL:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):AstraZeneca:Active (exists now) ; Consultant:Medtronic:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Pfizer:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):MeMed:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Abbott:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Cytovale:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):Inflammatix:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):NCATS:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):NINDS:Active (exists now) ; Research Funding (PI or named investigator):NHLBI:Active (exists now) | Jestin Carlson: No Answer | Mohamud Daya: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Jonathan Elmer: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Tadahiro Goto: No Answer | Francis Guyette: DO NOT have relevant financial relationships | Ahamed Idris: No Answer
Meeting Info:

Resuscitation Science Symposium 2025

2025

New Orleans, Louisiana

Session Info:

Moderated Digital Poster Session 1

Saturday, 11/08/2025 , 05:15PM - 05:45PM

ReSS25 Moderated Digital Poster

More abstracts on this topic:
A Novel EMR-Based Algorithm with the Virtual Echocardiography Screening Tool (VEST) to Screen Patients for Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension

Narowska Gabriela, Anand Suneesh, Gangireddy Chethan, Enevoldsen John, Keane Martin, Edmundowicz Daniel, Forfia Paul, Vaidya Anjali

Categorizing Witnessed Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest by Bystander Type

Shekhar Aditya, Stebel Jacob, Mitra Avir, Kimbrell Joshua, Mader Timothy, Abbott Ethan

More abstracts from these authors:
Sequence of Epinephrine Administration and Advanced Airway Management for Adult Patients with Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest

Okubo Masashi, Amagasa Shunsuke, Callaway Clifton, Guyette Francis, Martin-gill Christian, Ramgopal Sriram, Wang Henry

Airway Opening Index in Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation

Nassal Michelle, Carlson Jestin, Stephens Shannon, Panchal Ashish, Wang Henry, Smith Rachel, Idris Ahamed, Jaureguibeitia Xabier, Aramendi Elisabete, Elola Andoni, Daya Mohamud, Nichol Graham, Aufderheide Tom

You have to be authorized to contact abstract author. Please, Login
Not Available